TheLakeInsiderThe insider's guide to America's luxury lakes
Black Lake
Black Lake · Off the tourist map

Where the people who live here eat.

The bar that doesn't advertise. The Tuesday-night dinner you'd never find by Googling. The donut shop that sells out by ten.

Restaurants

3 stops
  • Hammond
    Mack's Restaurant & Inn
    Editor's pick

    Restaurant-and-motel combination on County Route 6 with a back deck built for watching boat traffic come off the lake. Open Thursday through Sunday only. The private boat ramp and fish-cleaning station out back matter more here than the menu — this is where the tournament crowd docks for the afternoon. Free Wi-Fi, and they'll refill a propane tank for guests staying in one of the rooms.

    Thu–Sat noon–9pm, Sun noon–7pm$$(315) 375-8612
  • Morristown
    Turner Inn

    Burger-and-fish joint in Morristown that's been feeding the county for decades — hamburgers, fries, and a fish basket sized for someone who worked outside all day. No pretense, no water view like Ella's a block over, just a full plate for a fair price and the kind of portions that make the reputation do the advertising.

    $(315) 375-4020
  • Brier Hill
    Sid's Place

    Pizza-and-wings spot in Brier Hill, near enough to Jacques Cartier State Park to catch the after-beach crowd. Kathy and Pete Hunter make the dough from scratch every morning; the attached garage was Brier Hill's first schoolhouse, built in 1822, which is the kind of detail that comes up if you ask. Order the wings alongside the pizza — that's what regulars actually order.

    $