TheLakeInsiderThe insider's guide to America's exceptional lakes
Editorial standards

How we choose, and what we disclose.

TheLakeInsider is an editorial publication about America's lakes. This page explains how destinations and stays are selected and where the publication has an interest.

Last updated October 16, 2026

How lakes and local businesses are selected

A lake enters the guide when it is a real recreation destination with public access and a commercial base. Each restaurant, winery, marina, and service is checked against the business's own site or an official source. We check for closures and renames, leave out claims we can only find in one place, and state when conditions such as water levels are time-sensitive. Where a lake has no winery, no brewery, or no verified grocery, the guide says so.

How properties are selected

Owners and managers apply. An editor reviews each application against five criteria: waterfront experience (25 percent), property quality and presentation (25 percent), amenities and hospitality (20 percent), photography (15 percent), and reputation and guest experience (15 percent). The score supports a human decision and never makes one. When the evidence is thin we ask for more information or leave the score blank, rather than guess.

Applying does not guarantee inclusion. Nothing is published until the owner has approved the text and photographs in writing.

Selection is independent of payment

Applications and approved basic listings are currently free. We do not accept payment for editorial selection. If paid or sponsored placements are ever introduced, they will be labeled "Sponsored" and kept visually separate from editorial selections.

Links and referral commissions

Booking links on a stay's page go to the property's own website. TheLakeInsider is not the seller of any stay, does not take payments, and does not receive a commission on a reservation. If a link ever earns the publication a commission, such as an affiliate product recommendation, it will be marked next to the link. We count outbound clicks to understand what readers find useful. A click is not a booking, and we do not report it as one.

Affiliated properties and businesses

These are the places where TheLakeInsider has an interest:

  • ·Smooth Sailing FLX and Lakeside Landing FLX on Seneca Lake are family-owned and operated, and TheLakeInsider's founders manage them. They are labeled as affiliated and were not chosen through the application process.
  • ·SpokeBnB is a separate business from the same family of companies. It offers training and website development to vacation rental operators. Using SpokeBnB has no effect on whether a property is selected, and applicant details are not shared with it.

Corrections

If something here is wrong, tell us at hello@thelakeinsider.com and we will check it against the source and correct it.