Editors' picks across 8 categories — the dock with the deepest channel, the winery with the view, the restaurant with the right wine list, the trail nobody's on at sunrise.
A steakhouse and saloon at 301 Main Street in Hill City, in a building its website calls the oldest hand-hewed log wall commercial building still standing in South Dakota. Online reservations are available, and hours shorten in November and December.
Visit ↗A self-pour taproom at 23858 US-385 north of Hill City with 28 rotating taps, scratch-made pizza, hot dogs, hoagies, and burgers, a creekside patio, and regular live music. Its posted hours are the winter schedule, and summer hours are not listed.
Visit ↗A marina on the south shore at 23060 Custer Gulch Road, also branded Pactola Marina, renting pontoons (17 listed), two 14-foot fishing boats, kayaks, stand-up paddleboards, and a canoe, plus seasonal boat slips. Life jackets are included, and pet-friendly rentals carry a $10 fee per dog.
Visit ↗A zoned earthfill dam on Rapid Creek, 230 feet high and 1,255 feet long, built by the Bureau of Reclamation from November 1952 to August 1956 to supply water to Rapid City and Ellsworth Air Force Base. Highway 385 crosses it.
Visit ↗A free Forest Service center at 22995 Highway 385 on the south side of the dam, with exhibits on western South Dakota's natural and cultural resources, mounted elk and deer, and a Black Hills Parks and Forests Association store. Normally open from the Friday of Memorial Day weekend through Labor Day.
A sandy beach on the south shore near the marina store and Pactola Point Picnic Area, about a mile down Custer Gulch Road from Highway 385. A day-use fee applies, there is no potable water, and dogs are not allowed on swim beaches.