The tasting room with a fire going. The bookstore that doesn't mind if you stay two hours. The museum nobody on TripAdvisor mentions. Rain on a lake is one of the better problems to have.
A show cave reached by a short boat ride across the lake and a bus; the tour lasts about two hours with about an hour in the caverns. Hours and prices differ between sources, so check lakeshastacaverns.com and book ahead on busy weekends.