TheLakeInsiderThe insider's guide to America's exceptional lakes
← Lake Sherwood
Lake Sherwood · The table & the tap

Where to eat. Where to drink.

Restaurants we'd send our parents to, breweries we'd send our brother-in-law to. Filtered by quadrant where it matters — sun on the dock at six, dinner by seven.

Restaurants

5 listed
  • White Sulphur Springs
    Gustard's Bistro

    A casual neighborhood restaurant at 759 E. Main St. in White Sulphur Springs serving starters, sandwiches, pizza, and entrees that emphasize local ingredients, per the county tourism site. One directory lists 11 a.m. to 8:30 p.m. Wednesday through Saturday, 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Sunday, and closed Monday and Tuesday; an earlier blog post gave different days, so call first. About 22 miles from the lake in a straight line.

    Wed-Sat 11am-8:30pm, Sun 11am-8pm (per directory); confirm(304) 536-2274Visit site ↗
  • Lewisburg
    Stardust Cafe

    A cafe at 1023 E. Washington St. in Lewisburg, in a former market building, serving lunch and dinner from a Mediterranean-inspired menu of locally sourced ingredients and house-made items. Hours were not listed on the county tourism site; check stardustcafewv.com or call. About 28 miles from the lake in a straight line.

    (304) 647-3663Visit site ↗
  • Lewisburg
    Hill & Holler

    A pizzeria and taproom that reopened in February 2025 in a larger downtown space at 886 W. Washington St. in Lewisburg, serving pizzas, calzones, sandwiches, and salads. A restaurant guide lists Tuesday through Sunday for lunch and dinner; call to confirm hours. About 28 miles from the lake in a straight line.

    Tue-Sun lunch and dinner (per restaurant guide); confirm(304) 647-4429
  • Lewisburg
    The Humble Tomato

    An Italian restaurant at 855 W. Washington St. in Lewisburg serving family-recipe dishes, known for its pizzas, plus pastas, sandwiches, salads, a full bar, and craft cocktails. Hours were not listed on the county tourism site. About 28 miles from the lake in a straight line.

    (681) 318-3788Visit site ↗
  • Lewisburg
    Briergarten

    An open-air, German-style beer garden at 121 Stratton Alley in downtown Lewisburg with 17 taps of West Virginia and European beers and snacks such as bratwurst, pepperoni rolls, and Bavarian pretzels. Hours were not listed, so call or check the website. Pin shows the alley and is approximate.

    (304) 520-4039Visit site ↗

Coffee & breakfast

1 listed
  • Lewisburg
    The Wild Bean

    A cafe at 1056 E. Washington St. in Lewisburg serving roasted coffee, espresso, baked goods, and smashburgers, with vegetarian, vegan, dairy-free, and gluten-free options. The county tourism site lists daily hours from 7 a.m., closing at 4 p.m. on weekdays and 5 p.m. on weekends. About 28 miles from the lake in a straight line.

    Daily from 7am; closes 4pm weekdays, 5pm weekends(304) 645-3738