TheLakeInsiderThe insider's guide to America's exceptional lakes
White County · IN

Lake Shafer

The livelier Twin Lake at Monticello, with pontoon and speedboat rentals, Norway Dam, and Indiana Beach on its shore.

Lake Shafer is the more commercial of Indiana's Twin Lakes near Monticello. Several operators rent pontoons and speedboats, and the Norway Dam Public Access Area offers hiking and fishing.

About Lake Shafer

Lake Shafer is a reservoir in White County, Indiana, near Monticello, formed by the Norway Dam, finished in June 1923. It covers about 2 square miles, averages 10 feet deep with a 30-foot maximum, and parts of the north end are as shallow as 4 feet. It is the more commercial of the Twin Lakes because of the Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park and Camp Resort, whose current status this guide could not confirm. Lake Shafer Boat Rentals says it stocks the state's largest fleet of speedboats and pontoons, and Indiana Beach Marina, Shafer Marina, and Sportsman's Marine are listed for rentals. The Norway Dam Public Access Area is named for hiking, bird watching, and fishing. IU Health White Memorial Hospital in Monticello lists a 24-hour emergency department, roughly 6 miles away. Rental prices, ramp addresses, and groceries were not verified.

Nearest cities
Monticello, IN
Airports
IND · LAF
Places locals point to

Start with these.

More lakes in Indiana.

The guide

Everything worth knowing.

Geography

Every stop, on one map.

Color-coded by category. Toggle layers, search by name or town, tap a pin for the editorial.

6 stops mapped
Open the full map →
Travelers also search for

Filtered by intent.

Same restaurants, wineries, parks — re-sorted around what you're actually trying to do.

The Insider Q&A

Answers, not algorithms.

The questions travelers actually ask before they arrive. Direct answers, the way a friend would phrase them.

10+ answers →