TheLakeInsiderThe insider's guide to America's exceptional lakes
← Lake Shafer
Lake Shafer · Insider Q&A

Answers, not algorithms.

The questions travelers actually Google before they arrive — and the answers you'd get from a friend who lives on Lake Shafer.

Getting there & around

Logistics

What is Lake Shafer?
Lake Shafer is a reservoir in White County, Indiana, near Monticello, formed by the Norway Dam in 1923. It covers about 2 square miles, averages 10 feet deep, and is the more commercial of the Twin Lakes because of the Indiana Beach Amusement Park and Camp Resort.
What's the closest airport to Lake Shafer?
Indianapolis International (IND) is the large airport this guide could name for the region, and Purdue University Airport (LAF) is closer but this guide did not verify scheduled service. This guide did not verify drive times to Monticello. Confirm current flights and drive times for your dates.
How deep is Lake Shafer?
Lake Shafer averages about 10 feet deep with a maximum near 30 feet, and sediment has made parts of the northern end as shallow as 4 feet. That matters for pontoons and ski boats near the north shore, so ask a rental operator which areas to avoid before you head out.
Groceries, gas, urgent care

Essentials

Where do you buy groceries near Lake Shafer?
The Walmart Supercenter at 1088 W Broadway St in Monticello is the grocery stop this guide found, and a Walmart listing shows it open daily from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m. with a grocery department. Monticello is the nearest town, so stock up before you check into a lake rental or campsite. Confirm hours in the off-season.
Where's the closest emergency room to Lake Shafer?
IU Health White Memorial Hospital at 720 S 6th St in Monticello lists a 24-hour emergency department, roughly 6 miles from the lake in a straight line. Its main line is (574) 583-7111. This guide did not confirm current hours, so verify before relying on it. Call 911 for emergencies.
Where to eat

Food & drink

Where can you get pizza near Indiana Beach?
Whiskey & Wine Saloon at 4986 E White Point Dr, under a mile from Indiana Beach in a straight line, lists pizzas, wings, and appetizers on its Toast ordering page and is shown closed Monday through Wednesday. This guide could not confirm fall hours or a phone number, so check before you go.
What's worth doing

Things to do

Can you rent a pontoon on Lake Shafer?
Lake Shafer Boat Rentals says it stocks the state's largest fleet of speedboats and pontoons, and a tourism guide lists pontoon, deck-boat, and ski-boat rentals from Indiana Beach Marina, Shafer Marina, and Sportsman's Marine. This guide found no prices or hours, so call before you plan around a rental.
What is the Norway Dam Public Access Area?
It is a public access area near the Norway Dam, about a mile north of Monticello, where hiking, bird watching, and fishing are popular. The dam was begun in 1922 and finished in June 1923. This guide did not verify facilities, parking, or hours, so check with White County before you visit.
With the family

Kids

Is there a water park or splash pad at Lake Shafer?
Yes, the Indiana Beach water park has a splash pad for younger children, a lazy river, and a four-story slide tower, according to a travel article, but the October 2026 Boardwalk Days page does not mention it. Check indianabeach.com or call (574) 583-4141 before planning around it.
Seasons & weather

When to come

Is Indiana Beach open?
Only on Saturdays through October 31, 2026. Indiana Beach's site lists five Boardwalk Days, October 3 through October 31, noon to 8 p.m., after the regular 2026 season ended, with $5 admission at the North Gate, free parking, and select rides at $5 each. Call (574) 583-4141 to confirm.